Top Navigation

Research Day Four: Under the Tree

I forgot two things about research: it’s very exhausting, and there’s never enough time to get everything done that could be done.

As Marnell and I stumbled out of our AirBnB this morning before 6am with our luggage, I wasn’t sure I could survive the rigors of another day of detective work. Things I had never expected to do in my research had me drained. Tramping through a cemetery in the rain, climbing through the woods with two strangers, navigating tall wet weeds in another cemetery, trying to decide whether to squeeze under the padlock of a locked gate or dashing through the door to get on the ferry and barely making it.

So my coffee was barely taking effect yet when we arrived at the Moravian cemetery in Bethlehem to meet our guide, historian Peter Hoover.

(Apparently Peter Hoover has a passion for researching cemeteries. Just last Friday he suffered a broken rib and a bad abrasion to the right arm pursuing a cemetery on a hill. So I’m not the only crazy researcher on the planet.)

Because we had allowed extra time for our commute from Staten Island, we arrived early at the Moravian cemetery in Bethlehem (not to be confused with Nisky Hill cemetery), to look for the grave of Captain Garrison.

I had the printout from Find a Grave, but all it gave me was an image of a stone nearly covered in dirt, with no legible words. Section A, Row 1. His son was Section A, Row 6, also illegible. His wife was Section C, Row 1.

In the misty morning, I wandered among the flat markers while Marnell took a nap because he stayed up late last night finishing work. I could find none of the graves, but neither did I know how the sections were divided.

Peter Hoover and his friend arrived. Marnell joined the search. We determined the system of the graves and found the marker for Mrs. Garrison, still easy to read. But the marker for the captain could not be found and by the appearance of the online shot, we wouldn’t know if we did find it. The son seemed to be the same, but Marnell shot some photos of a few stones that looked about like the online photo.

Two hundred and fifty years ago that Captain Garrison was lowered in the ground in 1781…

I wandered down the row alone. 1780. 1781. These men had died at the same time, so surely he would be one of these unreadable stones. I was sad, but I would need to be content with not knowing.

I stopped under a tree and looked at the tree pieces scattered in the muddy earth. Perhaps the stone on the print out had been under a tree, and that’s why the person had needed to scrape it clean.

Is that a stone there? I wondered.

I could see just a hint of gray. I scraped with my shoe and found stone.

“I’m checking this one under the tree,” I called to the others. “It’s in the right place in time.”

I picked up a short stick and used it to peel back the layers of mud. Legible letters and numbers appeared… 1781! His year of death. My heart beat faster… 1701! His year of birth.

The three men had walked over.

“Oh I think this is a B,” I said as I uncovered letters.

There is no B in Garrison.

“Wait, maybe it’s another R!”

There they were, two R’s etched side by side in stone. With a few quick motions, I cleared the top.


Completely legible in the flat, nearly 250-year old stone.

“That’s it!” cried Peter Hoover. “Oh this is so wonderful. You found it!”

With the help of an old credit card of Marnell’s, and ideas from everyone, we cleared it more thoroughly.

There, under the tree which almost certainly was not there yet, a man was laid to rest from a life of sin, a life of trials, a life of redemption and joy.

We wished for sand to make the words more legible, and chalk to search for the wording on his son’s grave. But like I said, there’s never enough time. The research is never done.

Later, we ate in the Sun Inn, where George Washington stayed three times. We scanned important documents and saw impressive architecture and artifacts and an ancient fire engine.

But finding the captain’s grave was the moment that made my exhaustion go away, and I heartily agreed with Peter Hoover’s decision to thank God for it on the very spot. 

25 Responses to Research Day Four: Under the Tree

  1. Sherri September 13, 2018 at 10:29 pm #

    That is so exciting!! I love history so much that even reading about someone else’s find fuels my fire!!

    • 500Admin September 13, 2018 at 10:58 pm #

      That’s great!

  2. Marlene September 13, 2018 at 10:32 pm #

    Peter is my mom’s cousin, so its fun to see him show up here, of all places. 🙂 He’s definitely unique, but I don’t doubt he was thrilled to pursue cemeteries with you!

    Best wishes on your writing, Katrina!

    • 500Admin September 13, 2018 at 10:59 pm #

      Thanks! We were honored to have his guidance.

  3. Barbara Bean September 13, 2018 at 10:36 pm #

    Hi Katrina,

    I am getting anxious to read your book. What a find!

    • 500Admin September 13, 2018 at 10:59 pm #

      It was fun!

  4. Barbara Bean September 13, 2018 at 10:38 pm #

    I am anxious to read your book. What a find!

  5. Claudia September 14, 2018 at 12:34 am #

    I know research is hard work, but it helps to have a lucky streak as well. 😉

    • 500Admin September 14, 2018 at 12:39 am #

      Maybe so!

  6. Barbara Ziesemer September 14, 2018 at 5:37 am #

    Another reminder that we all let “tracks” behind us! Thanks for sharing you exciting find! May you find strength for rest of your research.

    • 500Admin September 14, 2018 at 8:32 am #


  7. Beth September 14, 2018 at 6:21 am #

    It’s getting harder to wait for this book!
    Thanks for sharing your research days. It’s like reading the book before the book.

    • 500Admin September 14, 2018 at 8:38 am #


  8. Kelsie September 14, 2018 at 7:15 am #

    Unreal! Glad it’s you and not me, because I’m sure I would have given up before finding the stone. Take care, and more happy trails!

    • 500Admin September 14, 2018 at 8:34 am #

      Thanks! We had a long trail home but made it with no loss other than our muffler 😀

  9. Anonymous September 14, 2018 at 9:22 am #

    So cool Katrina!!! As others said, these posts make me more anxious to see the book! 🙂
    See ya soon!!!

    • 500Admin September 14, 2018 at 9:34 am #

      Sounds good! We stumbled home around 3am. 🙂

  10. victoria September 14, 2018 at 10:25 pm #

    What a coincidence. My husband and I were in a Moravian Cemetery near Watertown, Wisconsin just last week searching for his great grandfather’s grave. We had a picture too but it took us a while to figure out the system for where to look. Seemingly you just got buried next to the last person who died——so if you know the date of death you can generally find what you are looking for. Fortunately we didn’t have to dig and scrape since his stone was still upright.

    • 500Admin September 14, 2018 at 10:33 pm #

      I’m glad you could find it! In this cemetery, only flat stones were permitted I believe.

  11. Rosetta September 14, 2018 at 10:58 pm #

    Ahh, so wonderful! You’re making a great sleuth. Hanks for sharing your findings!

    • 500Admin September 15, 2018 at 8:18 pm #

      Thanks for following among, Rosetta!

  12. Anonymous September 15, 2018 at 2:16 pm #

    Wonderful, Marnell and Katrina, to get connected to your blog! Your highlight at Bethlehem was also mine. It was just so unlikely that you, personally, would discovered one of the most obscure stone in the vast cemetery. Both Chris and I were much impressed by your seriousness and feel of honest research as we worked things through out at the Moravian community. It takes a lot of work, bother and effort, but guess what. Books have a tendency of hanging around for a LONG TIME. May as well write one that is ACCURATE as well as inspiring, for the glory of God!

    I am also really looking forward to the finishing of your work on Captain Garrison. You have enough people interested now that you better not give up. . . . 🙂

    Peter Hoover

    • 500Admin September 15, 2018 at 8:17 pm #

      Thank you for your kind help and guidance! It was an honor working with such an educated scholar as yourself!

  13. Clara Byler September 16, 2018 at 10:30 am #

    Hi this was great reading about your research. I felt your suspense and exhaustion as Nolan and I have researched our ancestors and have stopped at many cemeteries to trek through the weeds and mud to find an old stone. It is so exhilarating to be able to find it! I can’t wait to read your book!

    • 500Admin September 16, 2018 at 12:33 pm #

      Thanks Clara. I hope I can do it justice!